IETF LTRU WG Last Call Issues List for draft-ietf-ltru-matching

Maintained by Martin J. Dürst, co-chair.

For more details of the discussion, please see the mailing list archive.

IETF Last Call

For BCP on draft-ietf-ltru-matching-14.txt (archived copy). Resulting in draft-ietf-ltru-matching-15.txt.

Issue Number Description Proposed/Raised Type/Status Discussion (main contributions only) Resolution

44 Formally update RFC2616 to fix error Larry Masinter minor substantial/closed - retracted
45 Proposed Standard instead of BCP? Larry Masinter procedural/closed - retracted
46 Legend Figure 1 missing via Mark Davis editorial/closed proposed: remove all figure legends (Martin J. Dürst) as proposed by Martin (title replacing legend for Fig. 3)
47 Improve reference to XML1.0 Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - improve
48 Improve Acknowledgement Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed proposed text (Addison Phillips) use text proposed by Addison
49 Improve Abstract Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed more proposed text (Randy Presuhn) alternative C
50 typo in Section 4.3 JFC Morfin editorial/closed argeement -> agreement (Doug Ewell) fix
51 typo in Acknowledgments JFC Morfin editorial/closed Acknowledgements -> Acknowledgments (Doug Ewell) fix
52 some names seem to be missing in Acknowledgments JFC Morfin editorial/closed call to submit additional names no additions because none of the directly affected people asked for it (see also issue 48)
53 Topic/purpose of draft not (completely) described JFC Morfin editorial/closed impossible to describe every possible use of a technology rejected
54 not enough examples for matching algorithms JFC Morfin editorial/closed there are enough examples rejected
55 algorithm is undocumented JFC Morfin editorial/closed there is no undocumented algorithm in the draft irrelevant
56 scalability/interoperability problem JFC Morfin substantial/closed no need for interoperability at the level suggested by the comment rejected
57 matching draft does not respect registry draft (no requirement for well-formedness) JFC Morfin editorial/closed not requiring well-formedness is motivated by operational considerations

(later correction: non-wellformed tags or ranges will simply not match anything)

 rejected
58 no need to describe specific matching schemes JFC Morfin fundamental/closed WGs that want to do language negotiation,... usually don't have expertise to come up with good matching scheme rejected
59 wildcards add usage limitations to registry draft JFC Morfin substantial/closed no actual usage limitations irrelevant
60 security section should mention potential for language-based censuring,... JFC Morfin substantial/closed this potential exists completely independently of this draft rejected

Second WG Last Call

Last Call announcement; Deadline for comments: Tuesday, May 16, 11:00 UTC; commenting on draft-ietf-ltru-matching-12.txt (archived copy); resulting in draft-ietf-ltru-matching-13.txt (archived copy).

Issue Number Description Proposed/Raised Type/Status Discussion (main contributions only) Resolution

35 Small editorial comments Debbie Garside editorial/closed - fixed
36 editorial comments John Cowan editorial/closed - fixed, with some adjustments
37 reduce could/would/might Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed John Cowan fixed in part
38 leftover from previous LC (issue 18) Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - fixed
39 explain codes Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - addressed
40 make abstract more meaningful Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - done
41 various misc editorial improvements Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed John Cowan fixed
42 question about extended filtering Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - non-issue
43 lower-case may/should/must Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed John Cowan fixed with some adjustments

First WG Last Call

Last Call announcement; Deadline for comments: Thursday, March 30, 23:00 UTC; section and figure numbers in Description refer to draft-11 (archived copy).

Issue Number Description Proposed/Raised Type/Status Discussion (main contributions only) Resolution

1 Breton is br, not be Stephane Bortzmeyer typo/closed - fixed
2 improved language (Sections 3.3 and 4.1) Debbie Garside editorial/closed - done, after detailled discussions
3 "matching" should be "filtering" for the whole document JFC Morfin major editorial/closed - rejected
4 Figure 3 is in violation with 4.3 JFC Morfin minor substantive/closed - rejected
5 Sec. 4.1 laborious and indigestible, too many semi-constraints JFC Morfin substantive/closed - rejected
6 Security considerations are inapproriate JFC Morfin split up (into only one new issue, see issue 8) - split
7 Improve structure of sections 3.3 and 4.1 JFC Morfin editorial/closed - rejected
8 Document additional risks (mass profiling) resulting from generalized matching methods. JFC Morfin substantive/closed - rejected
9 (MJD-A) Citation: 3066 or 3066bis Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - rejected
10 (MJD-B) Move last para of 2.2 somewhere else Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - moved and rephrased
11

(MJD-C)

 Fix ignored by most matching schemes in 2.2 Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - fixed
12 (MJD-D) Check/clarify where we only mention Implementations (four cases) Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - checked and fixed where appropriate
13 (MJD-E) Clarify start of 3.2.2 Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - fixed
14 (MJD-F) Explain why '*' only relevant in first position Martin J. Dürst explanatory/closed - done
15 (MJD-G) Tweak 1st sentence of 3.3 Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - rejected
16 (MJD-H) Readability of 2nd para of 4.1 Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - fixed
17 (MJD-I) Explain differences between filtering and lookup for range selection Martin J. Dürst explanatory/closed - explanation added
18 (MJD-J) 1st para of 4.3 Martin J. Dürst editorial/deferred see issue 38 agreed, but not fixed yet
19 (MJD-K) Remove empty Changes section Martin J. Dürst editorial/closed - removed
20 Exchange tag and range in 3.2.1 (one instance) Felix Sazaki editorial/closed - exchanged
21 Objection to ignoring '*' in non-1st position Kent Karlsson substantial/closed - rejected (Kent Karlsson disagrees)
22 Improve description of filtering with '*' algorithm Kent Karlsson editorial/closed John Cowan, one more thread addopted John's text (tweaking thread)
23 Add dot to Yahoo! Inc (2 places) Randy Presuhn editorial/closed - done
24 Simplify definition of basic language range Randy Presuhn editorial/closed - done
25 Add reference to HTTP errata Randy Presuhn editorial/closed - done
26 may not → do not necessarily Randy Presuhn editorial/closed - done
27 Names for months in references (2 places) Randy Presuhn editorial/closed - done
28 remove spam protection in email addresses Randy Presuhn editorial/closed - done
29 Provide a way for referencing specs to identify algorithms used Randy Presuhn substantial/closed - partially addressed
30 Remove MAY use different matching schemes Randy Presuhn substantial/closed - removed
31 Problematic SHOULDs Randy Presuhn substantial/closed - fixed where appropriate
32 Don't talk about content returned Randy Presuhn substantial/closed - mostly eliminated content (John Cowan disagrees)
33 No requirements directly on implementations Randy Presuhn substantial/closed - fixed
34 Do not suggest access to registry is necessary Randy Presuhn editorial/closed - reworded